Rebecca West, The Harsh Voice

Rebecca West, The Harsh Voice. VMC pb 1982; first published 1935, 251 pp. Library copy

I looked over my previous posts on what I’ve read of Rebecca West’s fiction (links at the end). There are themes and attitudes in them that can also be found in the four long short stories (or short novellas) that make up The Harsh Voice.

Alexandra Pringle in the Introduction to this VMC edition says all four deal, ‘in different ways…with the corrupting power of money and hate’. I’d add that these powers also have much to do with people’s matrimonial choices and experiences, as Rebecca West portrays them.

Three of the stories are set in the USA (although one begins in Paris); the other in England. They all deal with the ways in which wealthy people allow the corrupting powers of money (and matrimony) to taint their own lives and the people around them.

In ‘Life Sentence’ the title refers to a man’s disastrous failure to break off his engagement just before the wedding. He knows the marriage will be a disaster, and it is. His wife becomes the new American woman who was emerging between the two world wars: a shrewd and ruthless speculator on the money markets. Her entrepreneurial acumen becomes her only interest. The man hates her, and appears to escape, but as in all these stories there are some surprising and sometimes not too plausible plot twists and outcomes.

The young women in Cousin Rosamund, the final part of West’s superb Aubrey trilogy, discuss what one of them calls the ‘queer thing’ about men ‘who want to marry us.’ What’s that, one of them asks. ‘Why, enmity of course’. Chaucer’s Wife of Bath begins the prologue to her Canterbury Tale by referring to the woe that is in marriage; her remarkably prescient character’s cynical take on disastrous marriages has much in common with West’s, but was written several centuries before her.

The men in these stories are a pretty sorry lot, for the most part. The startlingly bleak opening lines of ‘There is No Conversation’ could stand for a central theme in the other three stories:

There is no such thing as conversation. It is an illusion. There are intersecting monologues, that is all.

The inability of people to really listen to and thereby comprehend each other when they converse results in dislocation and/or misunderstanding; they’re probably reinforcing their own preoccupations or assumptions, or simply misconstruing. I’m reminded of a course Mrs TD went on and told me about, where she learned about the various levels of listening; much of the time we’re not really paying attention to what our interlocutor is saying (that would be ‘active listening’). We’re listening instead to the voice in our own head, preparing what we’re about to say – or even thinking about something else completely.

I found this to be one of the strongest and most compelling of the four stories. As in Kurosawa’s brilliant 1950 film Rashomon, based on stories by Akutagawa (I posted about it HERE some years ago), we get a story told from the radically different perspectives of the participants, each in their own way predisposed to insert their own interpretation on events: an ageing dandyish Parisian minor aristocrat, a selfish, womanising narcissist, and the dowdy, wealthy, intermittently shrewd American businesswoman he seduces and treats heartlessly. Her version of the story that he had earlier told the narrator is a humdinger, and puts his completely wrong-headed interpretation of what happened into a perspective that shows him up for the preening, self-absorbed cad that he truly is.

‘The Salt of the Earth’ is a term used of the woman who sets about correcting, as she sees it, the faults and mistakes being made by her family and servants. In fact, she’s a monster, insensitively interfering with other people’s lives in ways that render them either miserable or angry, usually both. It’s another story about the inability of a solipsistic person to really see (or hear) others as they are – and most especially, herself.

Her long-suffering husband tries to get her to see the reality of her cruel behaviour, and put a stop to it, but it’s a forlorn cause. The inevitable ending is carefully set up with delightfully malicious clues from the start.

I found ‘The Abiding Vision’ rather nasty. Another wealthy man loses everything in the Wall Street crash. His loyal wife has a sort of breakdown, but he’s consoled by the younger, prettier chorus girl he’d set up as his mistress in a smart New York apartment. She might have been expected to leave this business arrangement when he lost everything, but she too remains unaccountably loyal, loving and supportive to him. But as the years had passed, she’d also started to lose her looks, and it’s apparent that he’ll soon look for another, younger model.

He’s the unattractive epitome of the American individualist businessman; like the wife in ‘Life Sentence’, he was happy to speculate in stocks and bend the rules, even break the law, in the pursuit of wealth, and can’t really understand why he’s eventually held to account.

One other rather unpleasant note in these stories: there are quite a few racial and antisemitic slurs and terms that probably reflect the views and attitudes of some of West’s heartless characters, but also, sadly, the prevailing views of the time.

Rebecca West had been a fervent supporter of the suffragist movement, and would probably have liked to portray an emerging, independent kind of New Woman who’d shaken off the fetters of patriarchal society. But in these stories, as in the much later Aubrey trilogy, women still found themselves hampered by the social and cultural expectations of the wife and mother – or of the single woman. If she does manage to liberate herself, it seems to be at the cost of her humanity and compassion – and her capacity to love.

The title of this collection is taken from a poem by Richard Wynne Errington (no, me neither):

Speaks the harsh voice

We hear when money talks, or hate

Then comes the softest answer.

There aren’t many soft answers here.

Here are those links to my other posts on Rebecca West’s fiction:

The Return of the Soldier (1918)

Harriet Hume (1929)

The Aubrey trilogy:

The Fountain Overflows (1956)

Posthumously published, unrevised sequels:

This Real Night (1984)

Cousin Rosamund (1985)

14 thoughts on “Rebecca West, The Harsh Voice”

    • I think you’ll enjoy the Aubrey trilogy. She’s a fine writer. I didn’t say enough in this post about the high quality of the writing. I’ve liked most of the fiction of hers that I’ve read so far, but struggled to read much of the enormous travel book Black Lamb and Grey Falcon.

  1. Thank you for this thoughtful and fascinating review. I especially liked Mrs TD’s comment on the difference between really listening and just waiting to jump in with our own take on a matter.

  2. Really interesting to hear your thoughts on this one, Simon. It was the first West I read, a long time ago, and I was really taken with her writing. Some of the stories are harsher than others, yes, but I found them all very thought-provoking.

  3. Oh, Simon, I sometimes try to avoid reading your remarks because my to-be-read pile continues to pile up precipitously. Unfortunately, you have such a talent for making stories and books sound irresistible that I usually weaken and add one. These stories sound very interesting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *