Louisa Young, The Golden Hours

Louisa Young, The Golden Hours, Mantle, 2026. Hb, 437 pp.

Louise Young admits in a preliminary note to her novel The Golden Hours that it seemed ‘rank impertinence’ to write a continuation of her aunt Jane (ie Elizabeth Jane) Howard’s Cazalet sequence of novels – which I enjoyed enormously, and wrote about HERE.

The last of the five original novels ended at Christmas 1958; The Golden Hours starts four years later, and ends in the spring of 1966. Does Young succeed in capturing the charm, wit and sheer exuberance of her aunt’s ‘chronicles’ of the Cazalets? By and large, yes. Young has clearly read her aunt’s novels closely and attentively, and she shows the main characters continuing to exhibit the same mix of strengths and weaknesses, while gently introducing nuances and developments of her own.

We get the same borderline whimsical and unconvincingly cute scenes with young children, doing and saying bizarre, ingenuous things, alternating between brattish selfishness and endearingly loving eccentricity. Much the same goes for the grown-ups, too.

As in EJH’s sequence, the novel consists of short chapters, each focused on one, sometimes two characters. The three brothers, Hugh, scarred by his WWI wounds, sex pest Edward and struggling artist Rupert, are now the senior family members. The family timber business failed in the final parts of EJH’s novels, so now the brothers and their families have largely reinvented themselves, but are struggling.

Most of the best sections deal with the cousins Polly, now chatelaine of her husband’s stately home in Norfolk, and haven for many of her family’s waifs and strays; there’s also writer Clary, Louise, former actress and now running an agency for actors, and drifting, homeless beauty Juliet, who’d formed an unwise liaison in the previous novels with a close family member.

As I wrote back in February, EJH’s novels depict the huge social and cultural changes in English society before, during and after WWII. Young takes up this theme by showing the further shifts that were taking place in the early to mid 60s, especially for an upper-middle-class family like the Cazalets, whose fortunes were waning along with the dominance of their social class (although that class has the resilience of cockroaches). There are references to Carnaby Street and the Beatles, Mick Jagger, mini-skirts and dolly birds with Mini cars.

The complexities of family life continue to be the main subject. Family members keep secrets to try to protect others whom they fear will be hurt if they know the truth – and usually only succeed in producing even more painful outcomes. People don’t talk about things that they really should, hence producing more misunderstandings and hurt feelings.

The role of women continues to be subservient to that of men. Rising career women like the Cazalet cousins aren’t allowed to take out a mortgage to buy their own houses. Women have to suppress their own desires and ambitions in order to appease their demanding male partners. Their menfolk, however, take off and do what they want, despite the hurtful impact this has on their partners, as Rupert does with an ill-fated trip back to France, where he’d conducted a passionate affair with a local woman as a fugitive soldier in Nazi-occupied territory. He’s still racked by the guilt caused by his abandoning his lover and their child.

EJH’s women would probably just have grinned and borne it, while simmering with suppressed anger and frustration. Young, I think sensibly, shows how gender roles were slowly changing in this period. Clary, for example, does go off to Hollywood to oversee the filming of one of her plays. Her career as a writer is taking off, and she shows determination in ensuring that she isn’t constrained by her husband’s objections to her going off independently.

The final section of the novel moves us breathlessly into some highly dramatic situations that I can’t go into detail about here without spoilers. The last chapter ends with one of the most fingertip-straining cliffhangers that I remember reading.

I think Young has managed to succeed with the difficult task of producing a convincingly engaging continuation of the Cazalet chronicles. It’s more than a pastiche of her aunt’s novels; she catches the style, tone and approach of the originals, while gently introducing touches and innovations of her own that work well. I thought, for example, that references like a character ‘getting her head round’ a problem, represented stylistic lapses, but on reflection I think this is a legitimate linguistic development in keeping with the more modern timeframe, and the author’s sensible decision to introduce something of her own into the EJH template. It’s a blend that works. I look forward to reading what Young promises will be two further sequels in the future.

Elizabeth Jane Howard, Getting It Right

Elizabeth Jane Howard, Getting It Right. Picador pb 2015 (19821) 410 pp.

What a contrast to the Cazalet Chronicles (I posted on them here last month). Most of the characters in Getting It Right come from a much lower social stratum than the Cazalet family. Gavin is 31, a hairdresser in a West End salon, and still a reluctant virgin.

He’s too timid and diffident to make any important decisions – such as moving out of his stifling parents’ house, where he has no agency, privacy or independence. Whenever he encounters conflict or unpleasantness, he bottles up his feelings and adopts avoidance strategies. Inside his head, however, he indulges powerful unexpressed thoughts and reactions – like standing up to his boorish, lazy and demanding boss.

The same applies when it comes to sex (he’s fairly sure he’s not gay). He has erotic (but always unconsummated) fantasies, but shies away from any meaningful contact with women in real life – or any social contacts outside of his comfort zone. He’s far too self-judging/critical to believe that anyone could find him attractive, and languishes in the frustration and loneliness that are the natural consequence of these traits.

During the course of the novel this changes. He encounters several women who challenge his default aversion to relationships, and discovers that he does have the capacity to take emotional risks – to ‘get it right’ emotionally and romantically.

There’s some sharp observation, insight and humour in EJH’s depiction of these characters, but ultimately I found it a far less rewarding reading experience than the Cazalets, or even the other works of her fiction that I’ve read. Gavin is just too drippy and irritating in his Prufrockian timidity to find sufficiently sympathetic, and many of the secondary characters just don’t ring true.

There are several aspects to the novel that resonate interestingly now that I’ve read EJH’s memoir Slipstream (discussed in my previous post); much of Gavin’s lack of self-confidence, his sensitivity and diffidence look very like the author’s own, and like him she made some disastrous choices and decisions. His being exploited and patronised by other people resembles much of what she describes in Slipstream and in fictional form in the Cazalet sequence. It’s not enough, though, to make Getting It Right anything like as good as her superb late quintet of novels.

Elizabeth Jane Howard, Slipstream

Elizabeth Jane Howard, Slipstream: a memoir. Pan paperback, 2003; first published 2002. 493 pp.

As I said in my previous post, I enjoyed Elizabeth Jane Howard’s Cazalet Chronicles enormously. To fill the void that followed I decided to read her autobiography, Slipstream. She explains the title in the Preface:

Speaking as a very slow learner, I feel as though I have lived most of my life in the slipstream of experience. Often I have had to repeat the same disastrous situation several times before I got the message. That is still happening. I do not write this book as a wise, mature, finished person who has learned all the answers, but rather as someone who even at this late stage of seventy-nine years is still trying to change, find things out and do a bit better with them.

The self-deprecating, candidly vulnerable tone is set there, and the lucid, unadorned style that was a strong feature of the Cazalet novels. She’s not being overly modest there either; what follows is an account of her adult life (from teenage years onwards) of a person whose craving for the affection and endorsement never provided by her parents led her into affairs with a succession of unsuitable, usually older married men whose poise she mistook for maturity and sympathy, but who were almost all selfish and controlling.

Many of the details concerning these ill-judged liaisons resemble those in the Cazalet novels. Most notable, perhaps, is the gruesome sexual advances made by Edward towards his teenage daughter Louise, which happened to Jane (the name she was usually known by) with her father. In fact her life parallels that of Louise in many other ways: the disastrous romantic choices, the modelling for fashionable magazines, the failed acting career. Clary’s is the other character into whom she clearly poured much of her own experience.

This shows most glaringly in the affair Clary has with her monstrously self-centred lover and employer, who gets her pregnant then dumps her ignominiously. Jane’s affair with the writer of supernatural stories, Robert Aickman, has many similarities.

Peter Scott, the artist and naturalist she married at the age of 19 is clearly the model for Louise’s Michael (who lacks Peter’s interest in nature). Both have awful overbearing mothers with whom they have cloyingly close relationships.

It’s clear from numerous passages where this ingenuousness and lack of confidence and judgement came from. Jane’s parents brought her up to believe that ‘anything to do with the body was disgusting and that sex in any explicit form was horrible.’ Furthermore:

There was an ethos then that parents didn’t openly admire or extol their children’s behaviour and talent, and my mother certainly subscribed to that.

Later, when she told her mother that she was going to leave Peter Scott because she couldn’t be a writer while married to him, her mother retorted: ‘” What on earth makes you think that anyone would ever publish anything that you wrote?”’

Or there’s this family dictum:

Modesty was uniform: you must at all costs never get above yourself.

Jane took many years to discover that sexual pleasure could be mutual. Because of her inhibitions and hang-ups, she felt she was to blame for the serial failure of her relationships with men, and castigated herself: she was needy and hopeless, she felt: ‘Could I only see myself in the reflection of other people’s lives?’ Because of her ‘ignorance’ in such matters, she felt that she wasn’t learning from her mistakes:

…the less I understood my experiences the more I repeated them, each time becoming less aware of what I was doing.

Her affair with the polymath Arthur Koestler, another self-centred, ‘irascible, obsessive’ man with a ‘high voltage personality’, ended in the usual dismal fashion, her judgement once again letting her down: ‘I was too raw, too inexperienced, and too stupid to understand much of this…I was a small incident in his life.’

Her second marriage was to the author Kingsley Amis. At first this seemed an idyllic situation, then he started to show himself as another of those coercive, belittling monsters: he became a bullying drunk who openly disliked her. It took her years to pluck up the courage to leave him.

In the final few pages, however, she reflects:

I’ve made a good many mistakes, some rather expensive, but I think I’ve more or less paid for them. I’ve slowly learned some significant things – perhaps most of all the virtue, the supreme importance of truth, which, it seems to me now, should be continually searched for and treasured when any piece of it is found. This book has been in search of some of that.

Such disarming honesty and hard-won insight is refreshing and, I feel, touching.

Elizabeth Jane Howard, The Cazalet Chronicles

Elizabeth Jane Howard (1923-2014), The Cazalet Chronicles

This superb sequence of novels chronicles the lives of the upper-middle-class Cazalet family between 1937, as war is imminent, and 1947, when postwar rationing and austerity were still in place. The first novel was published in 1990, and the fourth in 1995. Then eight years later, in 2013, when Howard was 90, a fifth was added, set in the years 1956-58 (see the list at the end of this post).

I wanted to post about the sequence in its entirety, rather than about each volume individually. I recommend these novels as a hugely rewarding reading experience.

There’s not much traditional plot to speak of, despite the fact that most of these books are well over 500 pp long. Instead, Howard traces with sympathy, wit, tremendous humanity and quietly penetrating perception the intertwining lives of this extended family: their loves and losses, infidelities and jealousies, problems and joys.

At the top of the family are William (known as the Brig – as EJH’s grandfather was; much of the content of the novels is autobiographical) and his wife Kitty (aka the Duchy). Both were born in the 1860s, and they inculcate their children and grandchildren with the Victorian practices and values with which they were raised. This involves self-denial, reticence and emotional stiffness – though the Duchy is genuinely loving and kind to all.

The role of women is particularly prominent. This quotation from All Change about the self-denying Aunt Rachel is typical:

Her role in life was to look after other people, never to consider her appearance, to understand that men were more important than women, to attend to her parents, to organise meals [not cook them, of course] and deal with servants…

She even prioritises caring for her aging parents over being with her lover, Sid – much to Sid’s despair.

Much of the narrative tells of the three girl cousins, Polly, Clary and Louise, as they grow up into mature women, all of whose characters bear some resemblance to EJH herself. Alternating sections from vol. 2 onwards deal with each of them in turn, and extracts from their journals allow us to see their private thoughts and aspirations. They’re a fascinating mix of sophisticated and deeply ignorant – about politics, society and, fatefully, sex and relationships. Other sections focus on the other main adult characters, so the narrative propels the reader on and provides stimulating variety and contrast.

The Brig’s timber empire flourishes during the war years, when its products are much in demand. But as he ages and his three sons take over running the business, their lack of commercial acumen causes it to flounder, and the fates of their families in the later volumes become ever bleaker.

The two older brothers, Hugh and Edward, served in WWI; their experience of the horrors of the trenches have scarred them deeply – in Hugh’s case, physically, too: he lost a hand, and suffers from terrible headaches. Their younger sibling Rupert is a devoted father and husband, but hopelessly indecisive; even having to choose between struggling on as an artist – he loves painting, but it doesn’t pay the bills or keep his beautiful, needy young wife Zoe in the manner she expects – or joining the family business, for which he is palpably unsuited.

We follow the lives of the children of these three from their earliest years in the nursery, with governesses for the girls (education is wasted on them, the parents have been taught) and posh, soul-destroying boarding schools for the boys (because that’s what their fathers had to endure, so they do, too), to their own marriages and children.

Howard is particularly good at the depiction of young children. She makes them funny and a mixture of innocent and wise. I won’t try and quote examples, because out of context they probably fail to convey how subtle, warm and humane she is in portraying these youngsters. They form fierce attachments and equally fierce animosities, are by turns monstrously selfish and deeply loving. It’s fascinating to see how Howard deftly shows them maturing and developing into adults, sometimes changing for the better, but in some cases their flaws get the better of them and they cause damage to themselves and others.

What’s driving all this is the author’s anatomising of a class and generation that underwent huge change with the experience of WWII and its aftermath. EJH is on record as saying that she wanted, among other things, to write novels about the war that showed the lives of those who stayed at home.

It’s not just the children whose characters change over time: the adults, too, go through all kinds of cathartic experiences that in some cases harden and embitter them, while in others they transform for the better. Young bride Zoe, for example, causes her husband Rupert, whose first wife died in childbirth, all kinds of despair and heartache in the first years of their marriage with her shallow egotism. She’d been raised to value only her own stunning appearance; she has no sense of empathy. This leads her into serial flirtations, one of which ends so disastrously that she undergoes an epiphany and becomes a much better person.

One central feature is that many of the characters, especially married couples and parents with their children, fail to reveal their true feelings, or else they conceal what’s really on their minds. An example at random from vol. 5: when the Duchy is seriously ill, her daughter Rachel (mentioned above) tells the rest of the family that she’s ‘doing well’, is ‘on the mend’ – when she clearly wasn’t. Rachel ‘hadn’t wanted to worry them’. This causes her niece Clary to think:

Aunt Rachel would say those things. It was odd how, when people didn’t want to worry each other, they worried them more than ever.

Situations like this recur, especially when a partner or parent is ill, or undergoing a crisis. It’s difficult to convey here without sounding cliched how delicately and sensitively Howard demonstrates the way we make difficult situations worse by trying to protect those we love from painful truths.

There are perhaps more details about the domestic arrangements of a large household than necessary, and the servants’ personal lives aren’t always entirely convincingly done. Because of course none of the adults is capable of cooking a meal, maintaining the house and gardens, or looking after small children – that’s what the servants, nannies and governesses are for. The tough war years cause some changes – for the womenfolk, anyway, because the men wouldn’t be expected to do anything domestic. But much of this detail is pertinent, because it demonstrates the shortages that had to be coped with, and the measures that had to be taken to continue to feed, clothe and care for a large contingent of residents.

The final volume is perhaps the weakest: some of the dialogue, characterisation and set pieces have become a bit too familiar, perhaps – but it still has some of the heartbreaking and poignant moments that punctuate the first four that caused me after a particularly affecting scene to put the book down and take a breath.

I urge anyone who hasn’t read the Cazalet chronicles to do so. Mrs TD is on volume 4 now and is as hooked and enthusiastic as I was. It’s an enriching experience.

The Light Years (1990, Picador pb 2024, 554 pp.)

Marking Time (1991, Pan pb 2021, 592 pp.)

Confusion (1993, Pan pb 2021, 490 pp.)

Casting Off (1995, Picador pb 2024, 626 pp.)

All Change (2013, Pan pb 2021, 573 pp.)

Previous posts on EJH’s fiction (about which I had some reservations):

After Julius (1965)

Mr Wrong: short stories (1975 – but originally published before then)

Brief notes on Odd Girl Out (1972) and Something in Disguise (1969) HERE.

Autumn reading

A recent sunny break in Cyprus (away from damp, cloudy Cornwall) was a time for relaxed waterside reading, as well as on long train and plane journeys. Since then some drab autumnal weather has led to a bit more time for further reading. Here’s a roundup.

Two Elizabeth Jane Howard novels:

Odd Girl Out, Picador 2015, 19721. A rich young Botticelli beauty called (of course) Arabella disrupts the staid bourgeois lives of a married couple when she stays with them for a while. Arabella is a force of nature, a product of the post-sixties social revolution that challenged the class complacencies that had solidified after the war.

The way these tangled dynamics work out is well handled and reveals a great deal about the shortcomings of those decaying social structures.

Something in Disguise, Picador 2015, 19691. Very different from the above – but it does involve again a family’s fragility in the face of challenging forces represented by another kind of disruption: this time the horrible machinations of a horrible second husband. May had married him because he seemed kind, but discovers that he’s anything but. Her two grownup children escape, leaving her vulnerable. There’s a sweet love story, but lots of things go wrong for them all. Again it’s very skilfully crafted, if a little nasty. But that’s ok. Life isn’t usually all sweetness.

Henry de Montherlant, Chaos and Night, PMC 1966, first published in French 1963, translated by Terence Kilmartin. An embittered and still fanatical Spanish exile – a former anti-fascist anarchist who’d fought against Franco’s forces – has lived grouchily in Paris for two decades. He falls out with everyone, including his oldest friends and long-suffering daughter, as a result of his pig-headed dogmatism and sense of being the only one who’s always right (a flaw in most of our recent top politicians here in the UK). When he goes back to Spain to claim his part of an inheritance it’s evident that he’s going to encounter difficulties, maybe retribution – or even an epiphany. I can’t say I was too interested in finding out, but it was an interesting read.

C.J. Sansom, Dissolution, Pan Books, 2015, 20031. Borrowed from our travelling companion when I finished my own holiday books. It was ok, but far too long. Essentially a standard murder mystery, but set in a monastery at the time of the, well, dissolution of such institutions at the order of Henry VIII – his petulant riposte to the Pope’s refusal to allow him to divorce. Much corruption is exposed when his ‘commissioners’ charged by Thomas Cromwell to plunder these monastic estates set about their work with ferocious zeal. Matthew Shardlake is the lawyer/sleuth who investigates the multiple deaths that happened when his predecessor as a commissioner visited a Sussex monastery and ended up beheaded. Much of the period detail is fascinating, but it became a bit too intrusive after several hundred pages.

Anthony Seldon, with Jonathan Meakin, Truss at 10: How Not to be Prime Minister, Atlantic Books, 2024 (library copy). The title says it all. Chilling. Things can only get better.

Tessa Hadley, The Party, J. Cape, 2024. This was another novel (well, novella, it’s just over 100 pp. long) passed on to me by Mrs TD. I couldn’t see the point of it: two sisters meet some gruesome people, make bad decisions.

Robert Harris, Precipice, Hutchinson Heinemann, 2024 (another library copy). Very different from his last one, Act of Oblivion, that I posted on recently. This one tells the extraordinary story of the dangerously indiscreet correspondence (and affair) between H. H. Asquith, prime minister in his early sixties, and twenty-something aristo/socialite Venetia Stanley. Amazingly, the letters sent (several each day, obsessively) from HHA to Venetia quoted in the novel, full of official secrets, are all genuine. Hers to him are invented (very persuasively) by Harris because HHA burnt them when his career ended.

Harris ingeniously invents a troubled cop (aren’t they always in fiction) who’s recruited by the predecessor of MI5 to investigate when it becomes apparent that top secret documents and highly sensitive political details are being illegally sent to his girlfriend by the besotted, rather sad and possibly unhinged PM. Venetia wasn’t the first of his infatuations with much younger women, and she wasn’t the last. That all this happened on the brink of WWI (hence the title – although it also refers to Asquith’s increasingly teetering premiership) and during its first year makes it all the more astonishing. It’s another long novel but I rattled through it in a couple of days. Great fun. Once again it sheds light on the behaviour of some of our more recent top politicians, who have also demonstrated unbalanced tendencies.

I’ve also recently read a fascinating and sobering account of the wife of the first bishop of Cornwall, Mary Benson, by Rodney Bolt. He was not a very nice husband and father.

My neighbour lent me a three-volume history of our local area by Viv and Bob Acton. It’s a well-researched account with lots of interesting illustrations.

Elizabeth Jane Howard, Mr Wrong

Elizabeth Jane Howard, Mr Wrong. Picador Books, 2015. Stories originally published in the 1950s and 1970s, I think

 I’ve read one Elizabeth Jane Howard novel, After Julius (link to my post HERE) – a rather melodramatic tale of tangled, thwarted love. I also know of her as the author of the four much-praised Cazalet novels, about the lives of middle-class characters, with the focus on the women (from what I’ve read about them). I was not expecting the hair-raising ghoulishness of two of the stories in this collection, therefore.

Elizabeth Jane Howard Mr Wrong coverThe title story, ‘Mr Wrong’ is about a car bought second-hand by a nervous, lonely young woman called Meg; it turns out to be haunted by a gruesome murderer and his victim – who starts to come after the callow, vulnerable new owner. The narrative and the story’s  title subvert with grim relish the trite social assumption that all a reserved young woman like Meg wants or needs from life is ‘Mr Right’.

‘Three Miles Up’ is like a nightmare version of those cosy tv programmes in which minor celebrities chug along picturesque canals in narrowboats. The two men in a boat invite a mysterious young woman to join them – they find her apparently asleep by a tree on the canal bank. Things then take a decidedly spooky and sinister turn as they decide to explore an overgrown branch canal that’s not on any of their maps.

After a bit of searching online I discovered that EJH had worked as a secretary for the Inland Waterways Association. This was a charity devoted to the conservation and promotion of Britain’s canals and waterways that was co-founded by Robert Aickman, the writer of supernatural ‘strange stories’, and with whom she had an affair. This liaison also led to her contributing these two stories and one other to the collection We Are for the Dark (1951), to which Aickman himself added another three. Interesting that she should create such vastly different genres of fiction.

Although none of the other seven stories in Mr Wrong have a supernatural element, several are quite acrid in their depiction of disastrous marriages and other relationships. Spouses have affairs and fight with their partners; parents neglect their children. ‘The Whip Hand’ has a monstrous controlling mother of a child performer who shows signs at the end of becoming nastier than her mother.

In ‘Child’s Play’ a spoilt 18-year-old newlywed returns home after a row with her husband to seek solace from her doting father, who turns out to be a serial philanderer. Father and daughter treat the mother, Kate, with contempt.

This story has a nice vignette of the family’s appropriately sociopathic cat bringing a mouse into the kitchen, and ‘forcing’ Kate ‘to meet her glassy, insolent gaze’. It then ‘began to crunch it up like a club sandwich’:

She liked Kate, in a limited way, to share in her triumphs. In ten seconds the mouse was gone, she had drunk a saucer of milk, and was polishing her spotless paws. She kept herself in a gleaming state of perpetual readiness – like a fire engine.

Even the cat has an agenda in this twisted family drama.

Only one story, ‘Summer Picnic’, has a gentler tone, and it provides a welcome respite from this sequence of stories about edgy, tainted lives and loves.

I found some of the perceptions of and assumptions about sexual relations in After Julius disturbing, and these misgivings recurred in reading some of the stories in Mr Wrong. In ‘Toutes Directions’, set in the south of France, there’s a sex scene in which the reader seems to be expected to find the young woman’s submission to a man she’s just met as a kind of epiphanic liberation. Maybe I’m misreading, but I thought it not far removed from rape.

Although the stories are technically quite good, I didn’t much care for the author’s attitudes to her characters and their world of tension. The amorality and caustic misanthropy are depressing and borderline morbid.

First magnolias of springI’ll lighten the mood with a picture taken the other day in a local park – the first magnolias there this spring. My tree is still in bud.

Norway and Elizabeth Jane Howard, After Julius

Oslo opera house

Oslo opera house with the almost finished new Edvard Munch museum to its right

This is my first post since returning from a break in Norway. Three days in Oslo, a lovely city, with floating saunas in the harbour opposite the dramatic sloping roof of the Opera House – designed to look like a glacier. You can walk to the top and get a great view from the top.

Long train trip to Bergen, which at first we found a letdown after Oslo, but it grew on us. Then the Hurtigruten ferry (the name means ‘rapid route’) up the coast, over the northernmost tip of the country and back down yet another fjord into Kirkenes (‘church on a promontory’) just a few kilometres from the Russian and Finnish borders to the south and east. It was one of the most bombed cities in WWII, and has suffered greatly over the years from invasions and occupations by hostile forces.

Elizabeth Jane Howard, After Julius coverI read the two books I took with me. First was Elizabeth Jane Howard, After Julius. Picador paperback, 2015, 339pp. 19651. This was the first in a bundle I bought for a ridiculously low price from the Book People, a budget UK online bookseller. Jacqui Wine recommended this at her blog as the best one to start with.

I enjoyed the crisp, intelligent writing style, and the observations of characters were astute. In this respect EJH reminded me of Elizabeth Taylor: both writers are good at depicting lonely, unfulfilled, thwarted women. Esme is particularly well drawn: at 58 she’s spent the past twenty years as a widow, her eponymous husband Julius having sacrificed his life by sailing single-handed to assist at the Dunkirk evacuation, with no previous maritime experience. It’s an act of suicide, for he’d discovered Esme was having an affair.

Esme’s lover Felix is fourteen years her junior, the love of her life, and she’d hoped when her husband died that they’d at last be able to be together. She’s disappointed. Now, twenty years on, he’s invited himself to a weekend at her country house in Sussex. Her two daughters are there, both also unhappy in love.

The narrative is structured with poise and skill: the three parts deal with the three days of the weekend, with frequent glimpses into the past lives of the main characters that gradually explain how they’ve become the people they are. Five of the chapters in each part take the restricted viewpoint in turn of each of these main characters, with the sixth being a culminating set group piece, usually ending in disaster or farce. Events become complicated, enlightening or humiliating for all of these five characters, as revelations are made that transform their views of themselves and each other. There’s some dark humour to leaven the rather melodramatic plot, and a particularly poignant section in which, in flashback, the fate of Julius is recounted.

It’s a novel of set pieces, such as country house meals and rural walks. Descriptions of interiors and the outdoors are delicately done, integral to the unfolding of character and relationships. The housekeeper’s cat is a fine feline portrait.

Like Jacqui, however (link to her post here) I had grave reservations about some of the sexual relations. Howard is astute about the dawning sexual liberation of the early sixties, with some frank and touching insights into its consequences. It wasn’t the outspokenness that disturbed me; it was her portrayal of abusive and controlling treatment of women by some of the male characters without any apparent sense that this was reprehensible. Unfortunately this ruined for me what had otherwise been an entertaining and well written novel.

The men are weakly done, too. Esme’s anxious and vulnerable younger daughter Emma has brought home an uncouth, working-class boor called Dan Brick (apt name) who we are intended to believe is a poet. She works at the family publishing firm, and he’s supposed to be a literary genius. Yet he shows no sensitivity to or interest in language, culture or people. He’s an inverted snob, scorning the privileged lives of these wealthy people from a world so different from his. He’s a character who doesn’t ring true at all, and this seriously weakens the novel. I found it impossible to believe that a young woman like Emma would be attracted to such a brute.

I wasn’t entirely convinced by Esme’s former lover, Felix, either. Like some of the other characters he attempts to reconcile conflicting moral impulses (Dan wouldn’t even begin to understand such a concept), but ultimately he too behaves like a cad.

I was left at the end thinking that Howard wanted in some way to punish these lonely, desperate women. She shares some of the acerbic wit of Elizabeth Taylor’s narrators, but little of their generosity.

There’s another review of After Julius by Caroline here

I enjoyed the second book much more: Colm Tóibín, Mad, Bad and Dangerous to Know will be the subject of another post. There may be more on Norway, too.