Private Peaceful, by Michael Morpurgo

Michael Morpurgo, Private Peaceful

We went this week to see the stage version of Michael Morpurgo’s Private Peaceful. Adapted by Simon Reade from Morpurgo’s YA novel first published in 2003, it’s a one-man play about the final hours of teenage ‘Tommo’ Peaceful on the night and morning before his execution during the early years of WWI.

It was an extraordinary performance by the actor Benjamin Cain. With only a camp bed as prop and a stark backdrop of a shell-scarred, mist-shrouded no man’s land, Tommo frequently checks his watch and counts the hours passing. His terror and barely suppressed sense of injustice are palpable, and make for a deeply moving and heartbreaking experience.

He begins by reliving scenes from his childhood and family life in rural Devonshire. By frequently adopting the voices and personalities of the characters he encounters, he creates, with that magical impact that’s only possible in live theatre, the impression of a large cast of actors. We’d seen a similar feat in the live-streamed film of Jodie Comer’s extraordinary performance for the National Theatre in the courtroom drama Prima Facie.

During these early parts of the play we hear through Tommo’s ingenuous account how unjust and exploitative the class system was – a hierarchy that was replicated in many ways in the military.

When war comes, Tommo is reluctantly moved to enlist (lying about his age – 16 – as so many others did) when a recruiting campaign comes to his village. In another scintillating act of ventriloquism he enters the character of an onlooking old woman who taunts him with the accusation of cowardice if he doesn’t join up. This ‘white feather’ emotional pressure from the womenfolk (and others) of the time reminds us of the populist, bullying misconception about the ‘nobility’ of young men fighting and probably dying ‘pro patria’.

The trench warfare scenes are brilliantly conveyed entirely through the actor’s performance, reinforced by sound and lighting effects; he doesn’t even have a prop rifle, he just mimes shooting (and being shot at and shelled). This makes the terror and hellishness of endless hours under enemy fire that he endures more powerful than any realistic film representation (the story was filmed in 2012): the psychological damage is conveyed into the audience’s imagination through a kind of theatrical osmosis. It’s the visceral kind of experience only possible in live theatre performance.

Tommo is court martialled for refusing to obey an order in battle. It was a stupid order, which would have meant leaving his badly injured, much loved older brother in a shell-hole in order to join a futile, suicidal advance into the enemy guns. The programme notes point out that over 300 British and Commonwealth soldiers were executed for similar charges of ‘desertion’ or ‘cowardice’. The concept of shell shock or PTSD wasn’t considered seriously until years afterwards – which puts us in mind of course of the writings of the likes of Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon and, more recently, Pat Barker in her Regeneration trilogy of novels.

As the hours tick past and the inevitable climax arrives – the execution – the tension is almost unbearable. The cruel fate of this young lad, who’s probably only 17 when he’s shot by firing squad, is a salutary reminder of the potential for otherwise civilised societies to lapse into barbarity and class oppression. At least the UK government finally, in 2006, posthumously pardoned these men.

I’m writing this on the day after the US so-called ‘war secretary’ announced that an execution by firing squad in December of a former army major who shot dead 13 unarmed US soldiers at Fort Hood will be live streamed for the public to view. Only two countries in the world that still make use of the death penalty have done so in public this past year: Iran and Afghanistan.