Kate Atkinson, Shrines of Gaiety. Penguin, 2023 (20221)
I read this on our recent trip to Berlin. Our son and his wife were playing in a twentieth anniversary celebration of the club where they used to DJ regularly in the years they lived there; they left for Catalonia seven years ago, but had been invited back to perform a joint…I don’t know the current terminology: set? We were on babysitting duties, so took the grandsons to the natural history museum while the parents performed – the club celebration started on Friday night and ended Monday morning; they were on at 10-1 on Saturday morning. It’s that kind of club.
Kate Atkinson has been a bit of a hit and miss author for me. When she’s good she’s excellent. Shrines I’d place in the middle of her achievements: not great, but not awful.
It’s set in the sleazy world of Soho nightclubs in 1926. It’s the year of the general strike, so there’s post-war poverty, trauma and depression alongside the hedonistic excess of the nightclub scene. Maybe Berlin in 2024 isn’t dissimilar.
Ma Croker’s empire of five clubs is under threat: rivals have their eyes on it, and her paid police protection is getting greedy, too. Into this mix is thrown a feisty woman librarian searching for a lost girl who’s left the provinces to seek fame on the stage in London, but rapidly finds herself being sucked into the vice and prostitution world that feeds on young women like her.
It’s all put together competently, and it holds the attention most of the time, but I found it way too long (over 500 pp), and the characterisation is often more like caricature. Fine for reading on trains and planes, and while sitting in a Kreuzberg Airbnb while sirens wail outside and the temperature drops to 10.
The natural history museum was great.