More Henry James stories

Since the early days of this blog I’ve posted frequently about the fiction of one of my favourite authors: Henry James. After a long James-free pause (apart from a recent trio of posts on The Ambassadors) I returned to vol. 1 of the Everyman Collected Stories and finished the last five published there (pp. 1027-1237).

‘Patagonia’ (1888) is a story apparently written as a response to a story by Trollope: ‘The Journey to Panama’. A young woman crosses the Atlantic from America on the ship The Patagonia to marry her betrothed in England, but it soon becomes clear that what should be a happy outcome for her is anything but. The typical Jamesian narrator, a single, observing, marginal man who is clearly attracted to Grace Mavis, has to watch another man flirt with her and turn her head. Now aged 30, she realises her chances of marriage had become slim, so accepting this long absent fiancé who’s been a student for years in Paris seems her only option. Will she fall for the slick charms of this philandering fellow passenger? The outcome is left open. It’s not James at his best, but it’s another well-crafted story about class and sexual tension; Grace’s reputation suffers as the other passengers on board the ship notice what’s going on with this, as they see it, flagrant disregard of the decorum expected of young women in their relations with men. (Men can philander – is that a word? – with impunity, of course.)

The parents of 11-year-old Morgan in ‘The Pupil’ (1888) are another example of a James motif: the negligent, shabby-genteel parents who take too little care of their offspring. Flitting from one rental or hotel to another with bills unpaid, they indulge themselves and neglect their clever, observant son. A tutor is employed more as a baby-sitter than educator, but he soon realises that payment doesn’t enter into the terms of engagement. The master and pupil form a close bond – maybe too close, though there’s no impropriety suggested. When the parents’ financial situation becomes dire they even ask the tutor to take the boy off their hands. Dickens would recognise this kind of fecklessness.

 In ‘The Marriages’ (1891) we encounter another innocent, fervent young woman (Adela) caught in a web of parental intrigues and marital-romantic tangles that she thinks she ‘knows’ about (as in ‘What Maisie Knew’), but doesn’t. It’s a story where James excels at his use of the focusing technique, so we see events and characters very much from Adela’s far from impartial or percipient point of view. The irony and revelations that ensue are handled with aplomb by a writer becoming very much The Master (the title used by Colm Tóibín in his excellent fictional account of HJ).

There’s another headstrong young woman protagonist in ‘The Chaperon’ (1891). When her recently deceased father’s ‘formidable’ will is read, Rose (20) hears that there’s a clause in it, ‘if not exactly a provision, a recommendation singularly emphatic’, requiring her to live with her indomitable grandmother and aunt on the south coast of England. Instead she opts to live with her mother – another of those frivolous, selfish parents who don’t take good care of their own lives, let alone those of their children. (Btw, Edith Wharton deals with this theme in her so-so novel The Children.)

Her family and social circle are appalled by this defiant act. What follows is a reversal of roles: Rose becomes the ‘chaperon’ to her glamorous, scandalous mother, refusing social invitations that don’t include both of them, and gradually facing down the opprobrium of society. There’s that element again of the young woman who’s shunned for flouting received views of female decorum. Is Rose’s defying of convention and renunciation of her own chances of social acceptance an act of selfless heroism, or simply quixotic (a word HJ used about her in his Notebooks) and wilful. Why is she so set on protecting and supporting her profligate mother? Why such loyalty to a woman who deserted her? Is it a sort of romantic solidarity? Rebellion against the prigs who cold shoulder her? I’m not sure ultimately HJ really wants definitive answers to such questions, but he raises them provocatively.

HJ wrote a number of ghost stories, perhaps the most famous being ‘The Turn of the Screw’. ‘Sir Edmund Orme’ is an unusual example of the genre, in that the ghost in question only appears (at first, anyway) to two of the main characters. It emerges that the revenant of the title was jilted by the woman who is the mother of the protagonist’s love interest. It (he?) shows up to both of them at critical moments to check that the daughter doesn’t follow the example of her mother by rejecting this new suitor. As the narrator-protagonist says:

It was a case of retributive justice. The mother was to pay, in suffering, for the suffering she had inflicted…the daughter was to be watched so that she might be made to suffer should she do an equal wrong.

As often with these observing narrators, there’s a whiff of egotism about his response to events. The ghost, he concludes, ‘was on my side…he was watching over my interest…[and] was looking to it that my heart shouldn’t be broken.’

The story is structured as a frame narrative – one of those ‘MS found in a trove of papers’ types of story. This enables HJ to leave the veracity of the tale told in the MS open to question – something we’ve seen in several of the stories I’ve cited here.

So there we are. A mixed batch of vintage early-ish Henry James stories, each one well worth a look. Now for volume 2 of the Collected Stories.